The AFSPA is unconstitutional.
If you think that an area is full of evil terrorists, you go in there with an act like the Special Powers act, it is shameful and pathetic if 5 years are not enough for you to regain control of a civilian population, no matter how many weapons they have.
If you can't manage in 5 years, take 5 more. Still no? Take 10 more. But, seriously, if 20 years are not enough for you to regain any sort of control, then that is just super pathetic. And that is your problem, not theirs. 50 freaking years? Really? Are you serious?
That's just so sad, dude... That's just wrong. And intolerable. Unacceptable. Unconstitutional. And it should be punishable by death. Which still won't return the lives of the thousands of innocents who have been killed.
http://www.guernicamag.com/features/3282/mathur_12_1_11/
Fresh look on AFSPA – way you never thought before - Why the AFSPA is unconstitutional, and must be repealed immediately.
Either we admit that those people are the citizens of our country, and we grant them the same rights the rest of the Indians (are supposed to) enjoy, or we admit that they are a foreign territory that we are trying to keep under our control, and hence we do not grant them those rights.
If you think that an area is full of evil terrorists, you go in there with an act like the Special Powers act, it is shameful and pathetic if 5 years are not enough for you to regain control of a civilian population, no matter how many weapons they have.
If you can't manage in 5 years, take 5 more. Still no? Take 10 more. But, seriously, if 20 years are not enough for you to regain any sort of control, then that is just super pathetic. And that is your problem, not theirs. 50 freaking years? Really? Are you serious?
That's just so sad, dude... That's just wrong. And intolerable. Unacceptable. Unconstitutional. And it should be punishable by death. Which still won't return the lives of the thousands of innocents who have been killed.
http://www.guernicamag.com/features/3282/mathur_12_1_11/
Fresh look on AFSPA – way you never thought before - Why the AFSPA is unconstitutional, and must be repealed immediately.
"The only solution, it seems, for redressing the deep anchored hatred and pain is an apology to the affected people and their subsequent economic advancement. So-called dialogues started by fat ministers, muffled scholars and cunning bureaucrats will not work. The Army or the police cannot help as they do not address the matters of the heart. If India has to be a true democracy then it has to show that the Rule by Law is also a Lawful Rule – starting with an investigation into who first thought of these unlawful acts that facilitated the murder of Indians.
Doubts about legitimacy of Indian rule in those places have to be cleared on an ideological level and at grass root, people-to-people levels. "